Who's The Rat?

[Ra1th]

I don't think its so likely that the culprit will be a dead guy, why? same reason i stated before, because that's a terrible finale for the suspense. Tommy's allready dead, no one will care if we find out he's the mole. I'll eat my hat if the mole turns out to be one of the dead, or a random member of the tower.

Another reason tommy couldnt have done it is, that seems like a really petty reason for tommy go to the mallers. Tommy was just a really nice kid, he was an innocent victim of the war, his death weighs down on Michael, he's that constant reminder that war has serious consequences, and making tommy out to be the bad guy would ruin that.

[yarri]

I don't think its so likely that the culprit will be a dead guy, why? same reason i stated before, because that's a terrible finale for the suspense. Tommy's allready dead, no one will care if we find out he's the mole. I'll eat my hat if the mole turns out to be one of the dead, or a random member of the tower.




Another reason tommy couldnt have done it is, that seems like a really petty reason for tommy go to the mallers. Tommy was just a really nice kid, he was an innocent victim of the war, his death weighs down on Michael, he's that constant reminder that war has serious consequences, and making tommy out to be the bad guy would ruin
that.

((Nothing changes it is a terrible reason but a tragic one. He had opportunity and possible motive. Also remember Tommy was accused of theft and multiple members of the tower were down right nasty to him because of it. He was a kid.. Kids make mistakes and believe people who they shouldn't.
Tommy, was a nice kid but he was naivete and as a kid prone to mistakes. Unfortunately if he was the rat.. he wasn't able to survive it and learn from it. Nothing changes about him if he was the rat.. He is still an innocent victim of war and the situation they are in and his death would be worse and by far more tragic. That part doesn't change. But the leader of the Mallers Mr Davri especially Mr Davri (hope I spelled that right) is very charming and has the potential to be very persuasive. It wouldn't be hard to listen to him and let him talk. Tommy as any young boy would vent and receive instant feed back and reassurances. Remember that Tommy was not getting alot of reassurances from his Aunt Kelly who had adopted the Tough Love mode of dealing with Tommy.

(trying to post with quotes is a pain in the tush)

[itsallgoodie]

Now, don't get me wrong, I really like Datu. Sure at first he was a bit annoying and hard to get along with but really after the whole Samantha thing, who couldn't feel bad for him.

But, let me ask you. Could Datu be a snitch...I dont have a whole lot of evidence to back it up, but he has always sort of kept to himself and he is just nice enough to be the kind of guy who wanted to "secure" himself some safety by making deals and what not.

There's my thought. Tear it apart or help me make a point.

[Ra1th]

Now, don't get me wrong, I really like Datu. Sure at first he was a bit annoying and hard to get along with but really after the whole Samantha thing, who couldn't feel bad for him.

But, let me ask you. Could Datu be a snitch...I dont have a whole lot of evidence to back it up, but he has always sort of kept to himself and he is just nice enough to be the kind of guy who wanted to "secure" himself some safety by making deals and what not.

There's my thought. Tear it apart or help me make a point.

tread carefully child, there is a monster round these parts by the name of nikvoodoo, and those who question his datu theory be his prey.

[itsallgoodie]

hmm, I just read what he said and i have to say that is really the point I was trying to make. I support nikvoodoo. He and I are on the same page.

[nikvoodoo]

hmm, I just read what he said and i have to say that is really the point I was trying to make. I support nikvoodoo. He and I are on the same page.

I'm glad to hear it! I don't know if I could take on a tag team against funny muffins and a partner.

Don't worry though, I'm done arguing my point. I've made it, I've defended it, and its now up to kc to prove me right, or serve me my big ol' heaping pile of crow.

[itsallgoodie]

I'm glad to hear it! I don't know if I could take on a tag team against funny muffins and a partner.

Don't worry though, I'm done arguing my point. I've made it, I've defended it, and its now up to kc to prove me right, or serve me my big ol' heaping pile of crow.

fair enough, we will all have to wait and find out. but we will all know soon enough. its great to talk to people about this though. ^_^

[mem]

still leaning towards Kelly. she could be two faced or a plant and sell it all so nicely. I could be wrong too.

[cheesehead1493]

As much as it sucks i still think its Saul, he had previously been to prison, we dont know where but he does kinda hint at Eastern Bay. Im not really sure how he survived his first scouting mission seeing as the radio cut out. He also has always had a radio when the maulers seemed to be the biggest danger. Maybe he knew some of them and then when they caught him on the mission they saved him but made him be a scout. Idk just thoughts

[Wicked Sid]

Saul did not go to Eastern Bay for such a minute crime. As Burt says that place is for the worst of the worst.