Chapter 22 - "Our Doubts Are Traitors" - Part 1

[WestonWisdom]

Steven seems to obvious. Like he came back this episode to throw us off from the real shooter.

It does seem obvious, and I really have hope that Kc has planned this well enough to be placing hints before Steven's introduction.

[nikvoodoo]

Along this line of thinking, can we just take a moment to recognize how beautifully crafted this whole thing is? How many times do you watch a movie or read a book and you are this up in the air this far into the game about a mystery? Not only do we still not know who dunnit, we can barely eliminate anyone from contention, AND we can't even say for certain how many people are involved....

...or even if it is related to the same thing! We don't even know for certain if the shooter is the rat! I'm stealing a catchphrase: I'm lovin' it!

[WestonWisdom]

...or even if it is related to the same thing! We don't even know for certain if the shooter is the rat! I'm stealing a catchphrase: I'm lovin' it!

Perhaps you can explain, why is so little emphasis being put on Pippen's recognition of his shooter?

[rottenash]

Maybe the oringinal rat has now sided with the tower. Scratch said she had not heard from the rat in a long time. The original rat was worried that he/she was in danger of being outted. Kablamo Pippen! because he/she knew why he was sent there.

If Hope is dead, that means the shooter was not from the tower at all. Everyone there knows Hope is blind, no need to kill her.
-Hope is alive

The one thing thats bothering me is the shooting of the radio..why? tower attack? or to just throw a curve ball to destroy communications..this only means that the mallers will not be able to know whats going on either. You'd think the radio was a benefit to them.

[Dameon1213]

Goddamnit I knew who it was! The second he made Lizzie feel guilty! I fucking knew it!

[Leedo2502]

Steven seems to obvious. Like he came back this episode to throw us off from the real shooter.

Or maybe that's what KC wants you to think LOL!

Seriously though I think he came back in this episode to shoot Pippin in the face

[Teleportingtaco]

If Hope is dead, that means the shooter was not from the tower at all. Everyone there knows Hope is blind, no need to kill her.
-Hope is alive

Well we don't know if everyone in the tower knows Hope is blind.

[Leedo2502]

Along this line of thinking, can we just take a moment to recognize how beautifully crafted this whole thing is? How many times do you watch a movie or read a book and you are this up in the air this far into the game about a mystery? Not only do we still not know who dunnit, we can barely eliminate anyone from contention, AND we can't even say for certain how many people are involved....

...or even if it is related to the same thing! We don't even know for certain if the shooter is the rat! I'm stealing a catchphrase: I'm lovin' it!

Hell yeah Nik I agree with like 75% of this post (with the eception of the last line). I've already listened to this episode 2 times already and plan on going beck to where Stevie boy makes his first appearence to listen again.

But yeah the 25% I disagree with is that we know that the Rat is the shooter because if memory serves Steve was adamant about booting Lizzie and maybe thats why Tardust and Bricks knew who she was (Steve giving the mallers a BOLO on Lizzy after she got the boot). If there is another Rat I'd be supprised...

[smalls kenobi]

i think at one point, Kelly was the traitor. after Tommy's death she had a change of heart, so she stopped contacting the mallers. so the mallers send in pippin as a backup. once kelly got some alone time with pippin in the guard room, she then questions him to see if he's there to spy, or if his story about him escaping is true. she then finds out he is there to spy, she's been on guard duty for a while, she had more than enough time to come up with a plan. listening to pippin's final words, he seemed surprised at who and what that person was doing. it would make sense for it to be the person he had the long talk with.

[Leedo2502]

i think at one point, Kelly was the traitor. after Tommy's death she had a change of heart, so she stopped contacting the mallers. so the mallers send in pippin as a backup. once kelly got some alone time with pippin in the guard room, she then questions him to see if he's there to spy, or if his story about him escaping is true. she then finds out he is there to spy, she's been on guard duty for a while, she had more than enough time to come up with a plan. listening to pippin's final words, he seemed surprised at who and what that person was doing. it would make sense for it to be the person he had the long talk with.

Damn not a bad idea there!