To respond the the 1st post, I don't think CJ would mount a counter strike "guns blazing". It just doesn't fit her character. I'd be more intrigued by who all knew of the weapons storages away from Dunbar since CJ didn't like letting people leave even before losing the large convoy, I would imagine not many people knew where they were.

I think that whoever was with Randy at the waterworks station ran into Samantha and they were the ones who failed to rescue her. However, i have 1 doubt about that. I think more then just the those 8 (cj, sean, duncan, Samantha, randy, hope, james, k-man) survived those couple days. I think the clue 8th and grand gives us a clue.

How would a maller know about that? If they did, wouldn't it have been easy for them to find the other tower? CJ also asked Saul and Victor if they were the ones stealing from her. This sounded as if it was recent. Skittles is living off of MREs so we know he isn't. To me this points to there being 1 more Dunbar survivor somewhere, or perhaps that recently changed survivor with the note was the final one.