Its a good question, as to if the soldier on the ground, having heard Kimmets' order, will be liable for punishment.The MP is charged with enforcing the UCMJ, but as far as we've seen, he hasn't done anything wrong. He may well be the one escorting Cross to the stockade though. As far as
Kimmet going of his rocker, his decisions have been consistent, really. He's not being erratic, just conservative, and as the base CO, he's allowed to make that decision. It might be the wrong one, but
Michael doesn't have the legal right to disobey a direct order, especially one that could less to serious consequences. I think Michael will lose more then a stripe.