Who's The Rat?

[Th3_T3ch]

You ask me why Kalani didn't shoot Angel and radio the Mallers. Well, Kalani is smart, and after the war kalani realized that staying with the tower, at least until the Mallers get back on their feet, is the smartest way of surviving. Throughout Season 2 Kalani has been sticking his head in whomever is incharge's ass. quite frankly wouldn't you want to have the best position rather than going back to being the lowly criminal. Kalani also pushed for the party right before the war, he was also on guard duty that day. yes there may be some holes in my theory but it is pretty rock solid. at least it is the most thought out theory I have read.

[nikvoodoo]

You ask me why Kalani didn't shoot Angel and radio the Mallers. Well, Kalani is smart, and after the war kalani realized that staying with the tower, at least until the Mallers get back on their feet, is the smartest way of surviving. Throughout Season 2 Kalani has been sticking his head in whomever is incharge's ass. quite frankly wouldn't you want to have the best position rather than going back to being the lowly criminal. Kalani also pushed for the party right before the war, he was also on guard duty that day. yes there may be some holes in my theory but it is pretty rock solid. at least it is the most thought out theory I have read.

I would argue my Datu theory is just as thought out (and admittedly just as many holes), but I'm not in a "rehashing my arguments" state of mind tonight. We can all renew this conversation again after Chapter 20 ends and we reset this thread and re-vote (unless Kc reveals who the rat is in the next two chapter parts).

[Th3_T3ch]

I believe the mole has a strong possibility to be revealed in this chapter and if he/she isn't then I shall refine my theory and write it again.

[nikvoodoo]

I believe the mole has a strong possibility to be revealed in this chapter and if he/she isn't then I shall refine my theory and write it again.

I dunno....now that we've left the Colony (where I thought we could potentially stay until the season break) the revelation of Who's the Rat feels like it could be an excellent way to push us into the off season.

I can certainly see how it could happen in chapter 20 though. Hmm....

[chiefspider]

i went with bill, because he stole all the ammo and food - and was never really trusting. and i know he died fighting for them but maybe because he relized they where gonna kill him to i dunno just a thought, and wtf why would pegs ever betray the tower? she kinda a passifist lol

[MrScott101]

after reading the wiki stuff I have to say it has to have been Bill, as much as I wanted it to be kalani, it's not, it's bill.

[Hellbringer]

I'm on the Bill kick because of that mental patient story that was DVR'ed on the TV. That's my story and I'm sticking to it.

[mascaria]

I'm on the Bill kick because of that mental patient story that was DVR'ed on the TV. That's my story and I'm sticking to it.

What does Bill have to do with the mental hospital?

[nikvoodoo]

What does Bill have to do with the mental hospital?

Ink's real name was Bill Roberts. I think one of two things:

1. Hellbringer is confusing the two Bills.
Or
2. Hellbringer was being funny, but the interwebs obscured the funny.

[Hellbringer]

Ink's real name was Bill Roberts. I think one of two things:

1. Hellbringer is confusing the two Bills.
Or
2. Hellbringer was being funny, but the interwebs obscured the funny.

Yep, it's number one. I had to go to the wiki and look up Bill, and then I had to look up each chapter in the wiki to figure out where I heard the TIVO/DVR part. Of course, after THAT, I found the thread you guys discussed the zombie with the tattoos and how KC said to re-listen to that part for the "aka Ink" bit.
But, I'm still blaming the Tower's Bill for being the rat, but I cannot do it with my old reasoning anymore, so I will have to go with gut feeling on this one.