Who's The Rat?

[TCM Revolver]

wtf, who thinks pegs or burt is the leak? why? and dont you dare say angel

LOL I voted for Burt. My theory is basically that Burt never liked Michael being in charge. How better to get the tower to not trust Michael anymore than show his weaknesses. Just a theory. (do you think KC looks at these and laughs lol)

[Spud]

LOL I voted for Burt. My theory is basically that Burt never liked Michael being in charge. How better to get the tower to not trust Michael anymore than show his weaknesses. Just a theory. (do you think KC looks at these and laughs lol)

I would if i knew who it was

[StepLaugh]

I think this is one of the big mysteries on the show. Along with some people's past, and Ink.

What are some other theories?

Might get another thread going?

Team Kelly FTW!

[RamblinMike]

Agreed. IMHO Kelly apears to have a disproportionate amount of guilt for Tommy's death. I wouldnt have this feeling if she blamed the leaders for his death and showed some anger towards them. Instead she is solemn and reserved as if to say she doesn't blame them at all. She even was the first to step-up to take care of Saul (remember she was the one who wanted to throw out Tommy for hoarding the gluton free food). Add in that she suddenly agreed with Michael just before the Mallers arrived, as if to placate him, and it just seems evident that she:

1. Told the Mallers what they wanted to know (hence the lack of detail regarding Pegs)
2. Was promised something (protection for her and Tommy)
3. Had no idea that this would result in violence and didn't think through her actions
4. Holds her herself accountable for Tommy's death and Saul's injury.

I can't see how it could be anyone other than an unknown person (maybe a Maller plant?)

That's one helluva case. I vote Kelly too. Who else bets she'll try and atone for it somehow at the Colony?

It's surprising lots of people are voting Kalani, since he really didn't have time enough to betray them, and no motive either. And, for the record, I buy the story about him as a pilot.

[StepLaugh]

I on the other hand don't really buy him as a pilot. I could have been in the LA area for the whole time if he's making it up. I think he has an end goal.

[Hollomandious]

I on the other hand don't really buy him as a pilot. I could have been in the LA area for the whole time if he's making it up. I think he has an end goal.

But what possible end could lieing about that do? It's not like anyone was gonna go to Hawaii. Or overall, it doesn't really matter how much worse it is elsewhere, cause they aren't there. And during the boat incident we found that water isn't really a perfect barricade.

I just think he has an annoying personality. But it is, what makes him him. And there's always gotta be at least 1 doosh around at any given time.

[nikvoodoo]

I chose Datu.

For the longest time, I would swear by Kelly. She makes the most sense overall to me. But two things changed my mind: I relistened to The War chapter, and the person who first defends the Tower as a weaponless resident is Kelly. She is the first person to throw a couch over the balcony. She's trying to defend their home. I also keyed on Jim Gleason's reasons why Datu survived (thematically) in the stadium as stated on the We're Not Dead podcast. Datu has a never say die attitude and it serves him well. He survives because he has faith that he will. Samantha's fatalist approach to her situation lends to her destruction.

Since the encounter at the Stadium, Datu has adopted the fatalist stance (and become an insufferable annoyance). He's also got severe survivors guilt. When he returned to the Tower, he was crushed and couldn't care less. And he's the only one we never heard at the party.

Can't you just see him talking to the Mallers on the radio, depressed and choking up wanting them to come in and end his misery? He can hear the merriment of the party and it just grinds on his last nerve. Why can't he and Samantha be up there having fun? Then he gets more pissed that they aren't coming in to kill him fast enough so he fires off the first rounds to make them come faster.

So call me/it crazy, but I call Datu trying commit suicide by Maller.

[Ra1th]

I chose Datu.

For the longest time, I would swear by Kelly. She makes the most sense overall to me. But two things changed my mind: I relistened to The War chapter, and the person who first defends the Tower as a weaponless resident is Kelly. She is the first person to throw a couch over the balcony. She's trying to defend their home. I also keyed on Jim Gleason's reasons why Datu survived (thematically) in the stadium as stated on the We're Not Dead podcast. Datu has a never say die attitude and it serves him well. He survives because he has faith that he will. Samantha's fatalist approach to her situation lends to her destruction.

Since the encounter at the Stadium, Datu has adopted the fatalist stance (and become an insufferable annoyance). He's also got severe survivors guilt. When he returned to the Tower, he was crushed and couldn't care less. And he's the only one we never heard at the party.

Can't you just see him talking to the Mallers on the radio, depressed and choking up wanting them to come in and end his misery? He can hear the merriment of the party and it just grinds on his last nerve. Why can't he and Samantha be up there having fun? Then he gets more pissed that they aren't coming in to kill him fast enough so he fires off the first rounds to make them come faster.

So call me/it crazy, but I call Datu trying commit suicide by Maller.

ohmygod that is brilliant, i mean of all the arguments i've heard so far, and i think i've heard damn near ALL of them, not a single character seemed to have a proper motive to call in the mallers, i mean sure kelly is a class A bitch, and its possible she contacted the mallers but, it just doesnt seem to fit together all that well, same with Burt, it couldnt have been burt, he fought tooth and nail for the tower. Kalani seems possible but once again not enough motive, unless he's not who we think he is at all, so maybe kalani, BUT THIS argument, is possibly the best one i've heard! Datu was not at the party, this could easily be a case of the pressures of the zombie apocalypse being too much for him to handle.

and on top of everything i HATE datu, so this would be awesome! he'd be a traitor, no one would like him, he'd prly die a terrible death, and we wont have to listen to his bitching about life not being fair anymore. Datu just moved to the top of my traitor list!

[Spud]

i love where this thread is going
all your theories just draw me in more

[Onslaught]

I voted for Kelly, It's probably just because I just don't like her, I was torn between voting for her or Kalani because when Kalani showed up thats when the everything went to hell so I'm guessing he was a maller that was captured.