I just finished with season three.

I have to be honest, I really do not like this guy. First off, he comes across as a little spoiled brat over Lizzy to the point where he has screwed over plenty of people. Keep in mind, if Saul didn't set up an exchange, the battle at the end of season 2 would have never happened and everyone that died would not have. That also includes the torturing of Burt wouldn't have happened earlier.

Secondly, out of everyone this guy has lost the least. He tries to be a leader, but he's the only one with his mother, his dog, his girl and a baby on the way. He basically has a whole family while everyone else has next to nothing left. If anyone from season 1 were to go, either it has to be him...or someone close to him. Except for the dog, animal death is not enjoyable. I doubt Scratch would even do that.