I started this tread as I saw that KC has yet to begin one, I assume he is a very busy man and I feel we ALL want to discuss Burt as Gandalf... "You Shall Not Pass!"

Now I want to see what people believe should fill out the rest of the "Fellowship", I know most of you can agree that Riley is Legolas.

Gimili is Victor (since they bicker just like they do in the movie)

I leave to you to figure out the rest...